Okay, after Sir George (and really, let's just Knight him already) here is the rest of the list from People:
2. Patrick Dempsey
3. Ashton Kutcher
4. Taye Diggs
5. Johnny Depp
6. Josh Duhamel
7. Enrique Murciano
8. Leonardo DiCaprio
9. John Krasinski
10. Jake Gyllenhaal
Both good and horrible choices here. Also EvilT, EvilB, why no chiming in on this? Must I be the only grader of manflesh?
Anyway, Ashton Kutcher at #3 is preposterous. My cat exudes more sex appeal and I don't even own a cat. I love Johnny Depp and his disaffected hair so I salute that one; I only wish us thick hair guys could compete with our giant bushels of Afro.
Leonardo DiCaprio? Really? Well, if you like your men waiflike and flaxen like back in the days of rampant tuberculosis I guess I could see that.
The #9 choice, John Krasinski, is actually really solid. When I saw the name I didn't know who the hell it was but it turns out he's the guy from The Office (but not Steve Carell). I think I would date him, and he's about to become a giant movie star as evidenced by his smaller roles in two very "buzzy" films, For Your Consideration and Dreamgirls.
Enrique Murciano is the guy from Without a Trace. It seems to be a TV show of some kind. I wouldn't know him if he physically assaulted me and left a card that said "I'm Enrique Murciano."
Josh Duhamel is very close to not being worth even talking about. He was decent enough in the show Las Vegas but this is more a case of People Magazine star building than calling it like it is. Plus if you knew everyone on the list you wouldn't bother purchasing it which would make Mr. People Magazine Jr. very sad.
My final complaint is Patrick Dempsey. I haven't met a woman yet who doesn't swoon for him but I can't for the life of me see it. He disappeared for like a decade! Was he being sexy when he was passing out resumes? Let's call his sexy quotient what it is, a flash in the pan cheap kind of sexy that makes all of us feel a little dirtier. Wait, I just read that back and maybe that's what sexy truly is.
Crap. I hate you Patrick Dempsey. Call me.